WiFi or ISP

Guide

Internet keeps dropping?

Drops are maddening because they never happen while you're looking, or while your ISP is on the phone. One question settles whose problem it is: while the internet is down, can you still reach your router?

The short answer

If your router keeps answering while the internet is gone, the outage is your ISP's (or your modem's). If the router disappears too, it's your Wi-Fi or router. Catching that needs a log, because drops come and go.

The one test that settles it

Next time it drops, open Terminal and run ping 192.168.1.1 (your router's address, from System Settings → Wi-Fi → Details… → TCP/IP), and in a second window ping 1.1.1.1.

  • Router answers, internet doesn't: your home network is fine. The outage is past it, at the modem or the ISP.
  • Neither answers: your Mac lost the router. That's your Wi-Fi signal, interference, or the router itself.

The catch: you have to be watching when it happens. Drops that last 40 seconds at 2 AM, or every afternoon for a week, need something that checks all the time and writes it down.

If your Mac loses the router

  • Weak signal. At the edge of range, Wi-Fi drops and reconnects. Check signal strength (Option-click the Wi-Fi icon; RSSI below −75 is weak) and move closer or add an access point.
  • Roaming between access points. In mesh or multi-AP homes, a Mac can hop to a farther access point and struggle there. Turning Wi-Fi off and on often moves it back.
  • Interference on 2.4 GHz. Microwaves, Bluetooth, baby monitors, and neighbors all share it. Use 5 or 6 GHz if you can.
  • An overheating or overloaded router. If drops hit every device at once, restart it, give it airflow, and update its firmware.

If the router stays up and the internet goes

  • Look at the modem's lights during a drop. A blinking or orange online light means it lost the line.
  • Check that coax or phone connections are finger-tight, and that there's no splitter you don't need.
  • Restart the modem, and check your ISP's outage page.
  • If it keeps happening, it's a line or network problem only your ISP can fix. Get the evidence together first.

How to get your ISP to actually fix it

Support scripts start with “restart your router” and end with “it's working now.” What moves a ticket forward is a record: the date and time of each drop, how long it lasted, and proof your router was reachable the whole time. Five drops with timestamps get a technician sent out. “It keeps dropping” doesn't.

Questions

Why does my internet drop at the same time every day?

Regular drops point to something scheduled or periodic: heavy neighborhood use in the evening, a device on your network that syncs at that hour, or the ISP's equipment. Log a few days to see the pattern.

Why does only my Mac lose the connection?

Then it's the Mac's Wi-Fi link, not the internet: its signal, roaming, or the band it's on. Other devices staying online rules out the ISP.

Is it my modem or my router?

If the router stays reachable but nothing past it is, look at the modem's lights. A modem that loses its online light is losing the ISP's line.

Catch every drop, and who caused it.

WiFi or ISP is a free Mac menu bar app. It times your router and the internet at the same moment, says which side is slow, and keeps a log you can send your ISP.

brew install --cask coreyhaines31/tap/wifiorisp