WiFi or ISP

PingKit alternative

PingKit vs WiFi or ISP

These two are the closest apps around. Both live in the menu bar, read your Wi-Fi signal, and time your router against the internet. They differ on price, privacy, which Macs they run on, and how they measure lag under load.

The short answer

PingKit does more beyond Wi-Fi: network device discovery, an iPhone companion, and cloud uptime checks, with key extras behind a subscription. WiFi or ISP is focused, free, source-available, runs on macOS 14, and adds an IETF bufferbloat test with router probes.

At a glance

WiFi or ISPPingKit
PriceFree, source on GitHubFree; Guardian $24.99/yr, Guardian Plus $39.99/yr on Mac
Minimum macOSmacOS 14 SonomamacOS 15 Sequoia
Router vs internet latencyYes, with a plain-language verdictYes, side by side
Bufferbloat testYes, IETF responsiveness with router probesLag under load on iPhone with Guardian
Speed testM-Lab NDT7, on demandYes, including scheduled tests
Alerts for 2.4 GHz and weaker roamsYesNot found
Report for your ISPPlain-text report and CSVPDF report
Device discovery on your networkNoYes
iPhone companionNoYes
Source codePublic on GitHubNot public
Data leaving your MacA provider lookup per network, and tests you startUptime Watch targets on PingKit's servers; usage counters

PingKit details from pingkit.app and the Mac App Store (PingKit Agent 3.1.0, September 2026).

What PingKit does better

Breadth. PingKit finds and fingerprints the devices on your network and alerts you when a new one joins. It has an iPhone app that can show your Mac's dashboard, scheduled speed tests, uptime checks that keep running from PingKit's servers when your Mac is off, and a toolkit of traceroute, port scans, DNS lookups, and more. If you want a whole home-network dashboard on your phone, PingKit is built for that.

What WiFi or ISP does better

  • It runs on macOS 14. PingKit's Mac Agent needs macOS 15 or later.
  • Lag under load on the Mac. WiFi or ISP runs the IETF responsiveness test and times your router and the internet during it, so it can say whether the lag builds up in your Wi-Fi or past your router.
  • Wi-Fi alerts. It tells you when your Mac falls back to 2.4 GHz or roams to a weaker access point.
  • No subscription. Everything is free, and the source is on GitHub.
  • No analytics or accounts. Beyond one provider lookup per network, it only talks to the internet for tests you start.

Questions

Is PingKit free?

The Mac Agent is free, including monitoring and alerts. Guardian ($24.99/year) puts your Mac's data on your iPhone and adds history and trends; Guardian Plus ($39.99/year on Mac) adds email and webhook alerts, branded reports, and 90 days of history.

Does PingKit work on macOS 14?

No. The PingKit Agent requires macOS 15 Sequoia or later. WiFi or ISP works on macOS 14 Sonoma and later.

Can I use both?

Yes. They don't conflict, though running two monitors that both probe your router every few seconds is redundant.

Try the free, focused one.

WiFi or ISP is a free Mac menu bar app. It times your router and the internet at the same moment, says which side is slow, and keeps a log you can send your ISP.

brew install --cask coreyhaines31/tap/wifiorisp